By Ben Neary/NMWF
A large New Mexico ranch has reopened a gate it installed this summer that had blocked public access to tens of thousands of acres of public land. The ranch’s action comes as the NM State Land Office said it would withhold leases on over 100,000 acres of state trust land within the ranch boundaries if the road remained closed.
The Catron County Commission voted last December to abandon County Road A009, in northwestern Catron County. The request came from the management of the 500,000-acre Great Western Ranch, one of the largest ranches in the country. The road crosses a short length of ranch land before it heads north into miles of public land.
Catron County Commission Chairman Buster Green is manager of the Great Western Ranch. Although Green abstained from the commission vote to close the road, county records show he wrote to the Catron County manager in the days before the commission vote saying there was no reason for the county to continue maintenance on the road.
Green didn’t mention in his communication to the county manager that the road provided public hunting access. And he didn’t mention that once the county abandoned the road, the Great Western Ranch would then essentially have exclusive access to the hunting on the landlocked public lands.
The Great Western Ranch blocked the road in August with a locked gate, cutting off public access to about 60 sections of public land just before the start of hunting season. A sign at the newly fenced off road gave Green’s name and number as the ranch contact.
In response to hunter complaints, the New Mexico Wildlife Federation filed a request with Catron County for records on the road closure issue. In responding to the NMWF request, county officials discovered that commissioners had never signed a required formal declaration abandoning the road after the December vote. Although the commission postponed action in September on whether to vote again on the abandonment issue, the gate had remained locked.
The 504,000-acre ranch, including over 100,000 acres of state trust land, had been owned by D.R. Horton, a prominent homebuilder in Dallas-Ft. Worth, until his death in 2024. Horton’s family put the ranch on the market for $115 million and a ranch broker announced in August 2025 that the property had been sold.
Dana Vackar Strang, surface resources assistant commissioner at the New Mexico State Land Office, wrote on Fri., Nov 13, to Green and to the Catron Cibola Ranches, LLC, – the company that now owns the ranch – stating that the land office would not transfer the leases for the 100,000 acres of state trust land within the ranch boundary from the Horton interests to the new ownership unless the gate were removed and other issues addressed within 30 days.
“The closure of County Road A009 prevents public access to more than 25,000 acres of state and federal land and this road has been labeled a ‘primary’ road under the U.S. Bureau of Land Management’s (BLM) Catron County Transportation Plan,” Strang wrote. “It is considered essential management access and ‘closure would constitute a crisis,’ according to BLM representatives. NMSLO feels similarly as closure of this road directly interferes with our ability to manage state trust lands for multiple uses. It is not in NMSLO’s interest to lease lands for agricultural purposes to a lessee who takes actions that interfere with the rights of other authorized users of state trust land and that violate lease terms.”
The New Mexico Department of Wildlife pays the state land office over $1 million a year in cash and services to lease access for hunting and fishing on state trust lands.
Strang noted in her letter that Green is both ranch manager and chairman of the Catron County Commission.
“Although, Chairman Green did recuse himself from voting at the Board meeting on the final motion to vacate the roads and the most recent motion to ‘table’ the topic at the September 9, 2026 meeting, there is an appearance of a conflict of interest as he is also an employee of Catron Cibola Ranches LLC, who is trying to obtain agricultural leases on state trust lands that include the above-mentioned roads,” Strang wrote. “Moving forward, in his dealings with NMSLO, the agency needs clarity regarding the capacity he is acting in.”
An attempt to reach Green for comment on Tuesday was not immediately successful.
In addition to demanding removal of the gate, Strang stated in her letter that the ranch’s installation of the gate and associated fence had significantly disturbed state lands without required archaeological review. Her letter demands the ranch retain qualified archaeologists to perform a complete cultural resources survey of the affected area within 30 days and report the findings to the state.
Strang said Tuesday that the State Land Office also is working with the ranch to address some other issues that must be addressed before the office will consider issuing new leases. Strang said Green reached out to the State Land Office directly after receiving her letter last week. She said she didn’t know the exact timing of the ranch opening the gate.
Strang said the ranch interests continue to propose some alternative routes to allow the public to continue to access public lands behind the gate. She stated in her letter that none of the new suggested routes was satisfactory because they crossed private land and were not dedicated county roads. She said her office wouldn’t accept any proposed routes that could be closed off to the public in the future.
In order to be considered for award of the state land leases, Strang’s letter to the ranch interests states that the ranch must agree not to petition the county in the future to close any roads that would hinder public access.
Strang said she’s encouraged by the ranch’s response in opening the road. She said her office will monitor the situation to make sure the ranch meets all requirements before considering transferring the state land leases to it. If the ranch fails to meet the land office conditions, her letter warns that the state would give the ranch 30 days to remove all livestock, equipment and other materials from the state property.
Strang said the State Land Office encourages members of the public to contact the office if they find state lands have been closed off to public access improperly.
“We have a proven record of working to maintain access on state trust land,” Strang said. “Just like Game and Fish, we continue to get notifications from hunters or others who have run into a locked gate and we work as quickly as possible to get those rectified.”